No, I’m not pushing a premium movie channel package with your current television provider! I’m referring to the Brown County Coin Club’s 4th Annual Coin Show which will be here soon.
This event will be held at the Heartland Mall, in the vacant Corral West Western Wear store, on Friday, February 15 from noon to 6:00 pm, and on Saturday, February 16, from 10:00 am to 5 pm. Admission is free.
This show provides a taste of what collecting coins is all about. It is also a great time to get acquainted with the coin club. Feel free to approach a member and ask one of us what the club is all about.This event is not a big fundraiser for the club; it is held for the benefit of community members, interested local folks, and to promote the hobby of coin collecting.
We have lost a couple of dealers from last year, but we have gained several new dealers who will be making their first appearances at our show. Right now, we have about 20 dealers from across the state and at least four of the club members will have tables, including me. The Central Texas Treasure Hunters Club will have a table, too, to introduce you to metal detecting, another great hobby. One of the four “reputable” grading and authentication firms, ANACS, will be there to take your submissions for grading.
If you were in bookstores searching for the most common, collectible publications on coin collecting, the first most popular would be the Redbook of coins, which started in 1947 and is published annually. The second most common, though, and highly collectible is the Star Rare Coin Encyclopedia, by B. Max Mehl, who was from Ft. Worth.
Who was Benjamin Max Mehl, and why are his publications so sought after when it has been over 50 years since any were published?
In 1903, when Max began collecting coins, the most successful dealers were on the East Coast. Max, a Jewish high school dropout, realized that the only way he could compete was to promote the heck out of his business! Established dealers promoted their businesses in publications devoted to collectors. Max bought big ads in mainstream publications like the Saturday Evening Post to appeal to non-collectors.
One of his biggest promotions was to offer $50 for a 1913 Liberty “V” nickel that anyone would find and sell to him. This was about two weeks’ pay for the average working man of the day. (These trade for $4,000,000 each now!) Max knew there were only five of these minted, and he knew where all of them were, but that didn’t stop him from starting a nationwide hunt for these ultra rarities. There were stories of street car conductors tying up traffic as they searched the fares for one of these! Of course, none were ever found, but this wild-goose chase was the “gateway drug” for coin collecting for many Americans!
Maybe you have worked to accumulate all one hundred of the shiney, new state quarters, a D and a P mintmark for each state, each resting in its proper niche in the State Quarters Album. . . thinking, “Maybe in 20, 30, or even 50 years I will have a nice valuable collection for my children or grandchildren.” Does this describe you?
Putting together a collection of anything is a lot of fun. Waiting for the latest quarter to come out, watching for it in change, and plugging holes in albums are all gratifying. And, the State Quarters program was a great “gateway” into coin collecting, bringing many kids and adults into this neat hobby. But, what will the value of that state quarter collection be in 50 years?
Not much, I’m predicting. Why? There are two keys to making a coin valuable. Those keys are “rarity” and “condition.”
Take, for example, the 2004 Texas quarters. Did you realize that there were 278 million of the Philadelphia mint quarters made, while there were 263 million of the Denver quarters minted? These will never be rare because so many were minted. Imagine for a minute there were 263 million Rolls Royse cars made in 2004; there would be a glut of them on the market and none would be worth the super premium price they bring when the supply is low.
There are three kinds of coin collectors: investors, collectors, and hoarders. Generally, my articles are directed to those who build collections for the thrill of putting together a set of coins of some type. This article is about coin hoarders, and the joy they bring to collectors when a collector runs into a hoard!
Coin hoarders, just like those folks on the TV show “Hoarders” who accumulate various odds and ends, indiscriminately accumulate coins. Here are a couple of local examples. A few years ago, someone showed me her stash from her bank deposit box of the 2,600 silver quarters she had inherited. At today’s silver price, that’s nearly $15,000. Another club member recently went through another person’s inherited hoard. Among many other coins, he found 1,800 Walking Liberty halves, with a minimum value of over $20,000.
I will share two of the most famous American hoards, the Redfield hoard and the New York Subway hoard. Maybe my story will entice you to dig into that hoard you or your grandparent have stored away from years ago.
We have all seen shows such as “Pawn Stars” where the shop gets in an old and valuable item, but they won’t make an offer on the item until an “expert” has evaluated it for them. Wouldn’t it be nice, in the coin collecting world, to have these experts to fall back on?
Oh, wait, we do . . . it is called third party grading. There are four reputable firms who will take your coins, evaluate their authenticity and grade, and encapsulate them in tamper proof holders for long term storage.
The top of the line firm is PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Service). You must be a member of their “collectors club” or a dealer to submit coins to them. NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Corporation) is the next highly regarded coin graders. You can submit coins to them in the same manner, or members of the American Numismatic Association can also submit coins.
Harking back to earlier articles, you will recall that a coin collection can be anything you want it to be. It is not merely filling all the holes in a Mercury dime book, for example. That hole for the $3000 1916 D is impossible for many people to ever fill!
So, with a little history lesson thrown in for free, I have a short coin set that might make a good challenge for a coin collector—the coins of 1921.
In 1921, our country was suffering a post-World War I recession. Times were pretty tough for everyone. And, on the national political stage, since 1900 or so a different issue was also being fought over which still affected money policies for the country during the early 20’s. The country was still torn over the use of the gold standard and/or the silver standard to back our U.S. currency. (Contrast this to today; our currency is backed by nothing except the “word” of our government!) Since I’m not an economist, I won’t address this issue any further, other than to say that this required the government to start minting massive quantities of silver dollars to back the paper money. This, therefore, left less silver for the minting of the other coin denominations.
One of the most popular series of coins to collect is the Morgan dollar. These big silver coins were designed by George T. Morgan and were first produced in 1878. Each of these contain 77% of an ounce of silver, making one worth a minimum of about $22 at today’s price of silver. These were minted from 1878 through 1904, and production was then halted until 1921 for one last year of issue. At various times, these coins were minted in Carson City, Denver, San Francisco, New Orleans, and Philadelphia.
Part of the reason these coins were minted was the discovery of the Comstock Lode near Virginia City, Nevada. This was a huge silver mine that produced nearly seven million TONS of silver from 1860 to 1880 when it played out. Of course, with all that silver available, Congressman from the western states got the Bland-Allison Act passed in 1878, which mandated the silver dollar as the coin of the realm.
Looking at the mintages of each year they were made, there were about two thirds of a billion of them minted. Most of these are not rare. Many, in fact, are available in high grades for really reasonable prices. However, the 1893 S, the king of the Morgans, will cost multiple thousands of dollars since only 100,000 were minted.
So you think you might want to start a coin collection and haven’t decided where to begin. I have a suggestion for a collection that will be fairly inexpensive and yet have some intrinsic value in the silver content, too.
My suggestion, for a good starting point, is the Roosevelt dime. To make it even easier, you could divide it into two sets—the silver coins in the series, 1946-1964, and the silver clad coins from 1965 to date.
This series began in 1946, shortly after the death of Franklin D. Roosevelt. The dime is an appropriate place for FDR. As a polio victim, he had a close connection to the March of Dimes, a charity campaign to solve childhood diseases.
First, the silver portion. A set of 90% silver Roosevelt dimes consists of about 51 dimes. At today’s melt value of silver, these tiny pellets of silver are each worth about $2. So, a minimum price of any silver dime will be about this amount. Most of these coins in nearly perfect uncirculated condition can be purchased from dealers for $3 to $5 each. The exceptions to this rule are the 1949 S, the 1950 S, and the 1951 S. These three will run you from $50 to $100 for all three in uncirculated condition. A nice set of the silver Roosevelts, in uncirculated condition, will run you about $150 to $200.